The High Court has overturned a four-year caution imposed by the Health and Care Professions Council (HCPC) on an occupational therapist who fabricated employment references and misrepresented his professional registration history to secure a job.

In Professional Standards Authority for Health and Social Care v Health and Care Professions Council & Anor [2026] EWHC 2926 (Admin), handed down on 12 November 2026, the court allowed a Professional Standards Authority (PSA) appeal under section 29 of the National Health Service Reform and Health Care Professions Act 2002.

The case provides important guidance on the assessment of dishonesty in fitness to practise proceedings, the application of sanctions guidance and the requirement for regulatory panels to give adequate reasons for their decisions.

Background

The case concerned an occupational therapist who had applied for a position as a disability assessor with Advo Health.

To secure the position, he submitted a CV containing falsified information, altered the date of his first professional registration, created a fictitious email account to impersonate a referee and produced a false employment reference. He also fabricated an HCPC letter of good standing and subsequently provided misleading information to the regulator about his registration history.

The HCPC’s Conduct and Competence Committee found that his fitness to practise was impaired by reason of misconduct. It described the dishonesty as elaborate, repeated, calculated and very serious, recognising that his lack of relevant experience created a risk of inappropriate disability assessments and potential harm to the public.

Despite these findings, the committee imposed a four-year caution order. It considered that the misconduct was isolated, that the risk of repetition was low and that the registrant had demonstrated insight and undertaken appropriate remediation.

The PSA challenged the sanction, arguing that it was insufficient given the seriousness and repeated nature of the dishonesty.

High Court findings

The appeal was allowed on all three grounds.

The court found that the committee had been wrong to characterise the misconduct as isolated. Although the dishonest acts were connected by the common objective of securing employment, they involved separate actions requiring planning and execution over a period of time. These included falsifying a CV, fabricating a reference and misleading both the employer and the HCPC.

The judge concluded that the committee’s characterisation was inconsistent with its own findings about the nature and chronology of the misconduct. The behaviour could not properly be regarded as a one-off incident.

The court also found that the committee had failed to provide adequate reasons for concluding that suspension would be disproportionate and that a caution was sufficient.

The HCPC’s Sanctions Policy identified suspension as a likely appropriate sanction where there had been serious breaches of professional standards, the registrant had demonstrated insight and the issues were unlikely to be repeated.

Those circumstances were present. However, the committee had not adequately explained why it departed from that guidance or why a non-restrictive caution sufficiently protected the public and maintained confidence in the profession.

The judge emphasised that, although sanctions guidance is indicative rather than prescriptive, panels must provide clear reasons when departing from it.

Suspension substituted for caution

The High Court quashed the four-year caution and determined that suspension was the appropriate sanction.

In reaching that conclusion, the judge considered that the seriousness of the dishonesty outweighed the mitigating circumstances, including the registrant’s insight, remediation and low risk of repetition.

The judgment also highlighted the wider implications of dishonesty in professional recruitment, observing that misrepresentations about experience and registration undermine the safety and effectiveness of arrangements for recruiting and regulating occupational therapists.

Fitness to Practise News Straight to your Inbox

* indicates required

Intuit Mailchimp

UK Fitness to Practise News

Disclaimer: The accuracy and information of news stories published on this website is accurate on the date of publishing. We endeavour to update stories if information change. You can contact us with change and update requests. Where possible, we will link to sources. Content on this website is for guidance purposes only. We cannot accept any responsibility or liability whatsoever for any action taken, or not taken. You should seek the appropriate legal advice having regard to your own particular circumstances.

Insight Works Training

Restoration Courses

Courses suitable for any health and social care practitioner who is considering making an application for restoration back onto the register.

Insight Works Training

Insight & Remediation

Courses that are suitable for any healthcare practitioner who is facing an investigation or hearing at work or before their regulatory body.

Insight Works Training

Probity, Ethics & Professionalism

Courses designed for those facing a complaint involving in part or in whole honesty, integrity and /or professionalism.